Schuyler grew up playing soccer in NJ, then played at Duke University, and professionally at AC Sparta Prague, Washington Spirit, Reign FC, and North Carolina Courage. She has also competed with the US Youth Nation Team at multiple age groups, including two U23 Nordic Cup tournaments. At Duke, Schuyler was an All-American and Academic All-American. She won ACC Defensive Player of the Year her senior year and was drafted 11th overall in the 2018 NWSL draft. With AC Sparta, she won the Czech League and Cup.